We’ve all been there. You find the perfect pair of shoes online — sleek, stylish, maybe even on sale — and then comes the dreaded question:
“What size should I get?”
Order too big? You’ll walk like a duck.
Too small? Your toes will file a formal complaint.
When you can’t try before you buy, getting the right shoe size online becomes less like shopping and more like gambling — only you don’t win money, you win blisters.
But don’t worry. This guide will help you crack the shoe-size code — whether you’re in the USA, UK, or somewhere in between.
1. Know Your Foot Like You Know Your Face 🦶🪞
Before clicking that “Buy Now” button, let’s figure out what we’re working with.
👉 Measure Your Foot (Yes, Like in Kindergarten)
You’ll need:
- A piece of paper
- A pen/pencil
- A ruler
- Socks (if you plan to wear them with the shoes)
Steps:
- Stand on the paper (preferably on a hard floor).
- Trace the outline of your foot (both feet, please — they might be different sizes).
- Measure the distance from your heel to the tip of your longest toe.
- Note down both feet’s measurements in inches and centimeters.
Pro Tip: Measure your feet in the evening. Feet swell during the day. That’s real science, not shopping drama.
1. Understand Size Conversions: US vs UK vs EU – Oh My! 🌍
You wear a size 9 in the US? That might be an 8 in the UK. Or a 42 in the EU. Welcome to the wild world of international sizing.
| Region | Men’s Size | Women’s Size |
|---|---|---|
| US | 9 | 10.5 |
| UK | 8 | 8 |
| EU | 42 | 43 |
⚠️ Warning: Brands don’t always follow these perfectly. Always check their specific conversion chart.
2. Width Matters (It’s Not All About Length, Okay?) 📏
Foot size isn’t just about length — width plays a huge role in comfort.
Width Letters:
- N: Narrow
- M: Medium (aka standard)
- W: Wide
- WW or E: Extra Wide
- B/C/D/E: Varies for men and women (sneaky, right?)
If your shoes always feel tight on the sides, you probably need a wide size.
Don’t keep blaming your socks.
3. Check the Brand’s Size Chart (Not Optional!) 🧠
Never — and we repeat — never assume your size is the same across all brands.
Nike might run small. New Balance might run wide. And don’t even get us started on Yeezys. Always check the brand’s official size guide on their website.
Most reputable brands show:
- Foot length in inches/cm
- Recommended size
- Fit suggestions (true to size, runs small/large)
Real Talk: If the brand doesn’t have a size chart, consider it a red flag. Or at least a yellow flag with caution tape.
4. Read the Reviews (People are Brutally Honest) 🕵️♂️
Online reviews are a goldmine. Search for:
- “Runs small”
- “Order a half size up”
- “Super comfy but size down!”
Look for reviews from buyers with your same shoe size or foot type.
If multiple people say the same thing, believe them — they walked so your feet don’t have to suffer.
5. Know Your Foot Type: Flat, Neutral, or High Arch? 👣
Just like people, feet have personalities. And they affect sizing.
Types:
- Flat feet = may need wider shoes and arch support
- Neutral feet = lucky you! Most shoes fit fine
- High arches = need more cushioning and sometimes sizing flexibility
How to check: Wet your foot and step on a brown paper bag. The shape tells all.
6. Try Brand-Specific Sizing Tools 🛠️
Some big brands and retailers offer tech tools to help you size better.
Examples:
- Nike Fit (in their app – scans your foot using your phone)
- Zappos: “How does it fit?” chart from verified buyers
- ASOS Fit Assistant: Asks your size in other brands and suggests accordingly
These tools aren’t perfect, but they’re 100x better than guessing.
7. Half Sizes Are Not a Scam (They’re a Lifesaver) 🤏
If you’ve ever thought, “8 feels tight, 9 is too big,” — congratulations, you’re a half-size person.
Many brands offer half sizes like 8.5 or 9.5. And yes, they do make a difference.
Spend the extra few bucks for half sizes. It’s cheaper than dealing with foot pain and returns.
8. Socks Matter More Than You Think 🧦
If you’ll wear thick winter socks with boots, size up.
If you’re going sockless in summer loafers, size down or go true to size.
Pro Tip: Always try shoes with the type of socks you’ll wear most with them.
9. Return Policies = Your Safety Net 📦
Look for:
- Free returns
- Prepaid shipping labels
- No restocking fees
Many top brands in the US & UK offer 30 to 60-day no-questions-asked returns. That’s your insurance policy against shoe drama.
10. Break-in Time ≠ Wrong Size ⏳
Don’t panic if new shoes feel slightly snug at first. Leather and some fabrics stretch a bit with wear. But if they’re cutting off circulation or giving you toe blisters on Day 1 — they’re too small, my friend.
Give shoes a day or two before judging. But don’t ignore pain.
11. Buy from Trusted Retailers Only 🛒
Where you buy matters.
Stick to:
- Brand websites (e.g. Adidas.com, Clarks.co.uk)
- Trusted stores like Zappos, ASOS, Nordstrom, Amazon (official brand stores only)
- Avoid shady sites with no return policy or contact info
12. Bonus: Use Shoe Inserts to Adjust Fit 🧼
If you end up buying slightly big:
- Heel grips help avoid slipping
- Insoles make shoes tighter + comfier
- Thicker socks are the age-old hack
Just don’t use a bunch of tricks to make obviously wrong-sized shoes work. That’s like taping your relationship together — not sustainable 😅.
13. Save Your Size Info (Be Smart, Future You Will Thank You) 📋
Keep a little note somewhere with:
- Your foot length (in inches & cm)
- Your usual US/UK size
- Brands you own and what size worked
Trust us, this will save you hours of stress in your next shoe hunt.
14. Kids? Totally Different Ball Game 👶
If you’re shopping for little humans, remember:
- Their feet grow fast
- Always size up a little
- Go for adjustable straps when possible
- Prioritize comfort over fashion (yes, even for mini Jordans)
Conclusion: Walk Smart, Shop Smarter 🚶♂️🛍️
Buying shoes online doesn’t have to be a gamble. Once you know your foot size, width, shape, and favorite brands — you’re basically a pro.
Just follow this guide like a checklist and you’ll never again end up with shoes that scream “Why did you buy me?”
And hey — if you mess up once in a while, don’t beat yourself up. That’s what return policies (and spare sandals) are for.
✅ TL;DR Recap (Bookmark-worthy!)
- Measure your feet properly
- Know your US/UK/EU sizes
- Always check brand-specific size charts
- Read buyer reviews
- Use tools like Nike Fit, Zappos fit assistant
- Prioritize width & arch type
- Choose retailers with friendly return policies
1 thought on “How to Choose the Right Shoe Size Online (Without Regrets)”